QUOTE(Anne @ March 12 2007, 01:44 PM) [snapback]95304[/snapback]
I don't think it provides or elicits many implementable strategies for business owners.
it becomes a nice piece of research reading in regards to the past rather than strategic reading for planning for the future.
That's an interesting take on it. I went away from TP thinking just the opposite. Well, sort of. I thought it did an outstanding job of approaching concept of "epidemic marketing" in a very abstract way while giving real world examples of other actual epidemics.
I thought the value of the book was the fact that it was so open ended.
I see so many books - from self help, to photography theory, to photoshop tecnique, to marketing, etc - where someone steps up and says "I've got it nailed. Now follow these same steps and you too will find success". I realize that's an over generalization of the point you're making, but I'm actually turned off when someone says "do this, this, and this to succeed" because everyone's approach to marketing and business are different, everyone interacts with people differently and everyone is coming from a different place.
Having too many "do it this way" points actually prevents someone like Matt from coming up with a great "sticky" idea of his own - his cute little Renaissance albums. His example takes the abstract concept of the book and finds a unique application for it that suits him and his approach to dealing with clients.
At any rate, I would highly suggest TP to anyone that's trying to step out and begin effective networking and word of mouth advertising. It opened my eyes to a lot of new concepts. The actual applications of those concepts are endless.
I've never heard of "Good to Great" Matt - I'll have to check that out.