swan
February 3 2007, 09:22 AM
QUOTE(Courtenay @ February 3 2007, 10:17 AM) [snapback]68919[/snapback]
I'm getting a new blu site, and am working on a new logo to go with it. I love the fleur-de-lis, but I am trying to stay as simple as possible. I'm just tired of looking at it now, and would appreciate any comments...good or bad! Thanks!
Here's my quick response to your logo, sorry if it hurts!
Nothing wrong with simple, I'm a big fan. But what I think you've created looks simple in the amateur way, not in the sophisticated way.
Your mark looks like clip-art. I'd prefer nothing to a piece of clip-art or a character from a dingbat font. I think you should either hire a designer or just keep the mark off.
I like the font you used for the biz name. It looks like Centaur to me, is it? Anyway, ALL CAPS IS DIFFICULT TO READ, is there a reason you are choosing to do that?
DWR seems industrial and cold, like IBM. Why go with something industrial when you're trying to create a fine-art feel?
I disagree that your positioning statement has to be spread out and match the size of the top section. Before (version 1), it had some nice shape to it--symmetrical without being blocky, now (version 2) it's starting to feel like a shoe box. I also wouldn't put it in the exact same font as the biz name, as you did in version 2. The script font you had was difficult to read and spaced poorly in v1, though. Again, you've gone to all caps. I'd only recommend going with all caps if you understand design rules and when to break them.
Looking closely, nothing really lines up. The line doesn't extend to the actual width of the text. The positioning statement doesn't really line up with the biz name. Computers make it pretty easy to make things exact, it just takes a smidge of time.
All in all, I'd recommend you hire someone. You can find someone without spending thousands. There are even several designers on this forum (hopefully, I won't get flamed for suggesting members in the forum purchase services from one another). While you may be able to tweak this idea and get it better, you'll not (in my opinion) ever be able to make it remarkable because you are not a designer.
My $.02