Ian -
OK - I've "stirred the pot", and I'm glad you're reading our feedback. I've pointed out a negative that makes me little crazy, and you guys have pointed out why. Thanks for that. However - I must admit, I am not crazy about the fact you are opening the .jpgs, resizing, and saving again. That does not effect print quality, I agree - but it does say something to me about the "archives" your "saving" for me. It's a loss of generation, and leaves me with a decision to make - do I make an extra step doing it myself, and then uploading? Mind you, I'd still need to create Q12 Jpegs for myself, or do just not worry about it. I'm not sure...
Let me point out some positives I've seen over the last two years, just to show I am not bashing:
FTP times has been improved ten-fold. It is rare my FTP "stalls" when uploading anymore. That's pretty huge.
The new interface is sweet - and it's a nice shopping cart for clients to look at.
Customer service has improved, even though I'm still getting complaints from my clients - but my clients are nuts.

Lab quality on printing has improved.
QUOTE(IanSiegel @ April 10 2008, 12:21 PM)

Hi guys -
Just wanted to quickly chime in here. When files are uploaded to Pictage we do have to create smaller proxy versions of each image so that when your clients are viewing them online they download quickly. We also will compress maxed out JPGs down slightly, but as was mentioned earlier, this is undetectable on even the largest size print.
The point of Pictage vs. other services is that once you upload you can technically be done. We can take care of all the marketing and fulfillment for prints, photo products, and within the next two months - even albums.
So yes - there is a bigger up front commitment as far as time when putting an event online, but theoretically that is compensated for by the time you save on the back end. It's as close as we can come to meeting our mission statement of "You shoot the pictures - we do the rest."
We've put an intense focus this year on making it easier to create an event (phase 1 of the photographer site redesign launched in March) and making uploads faster. We launched a plugin in January that allows you to upload directly from Aperture to Pictage, and the Lightroom version will be in Beta the last week of April. In addition we have a completely new standalone uploader (DEC) which will be launched by June. All three of these tools reduced upload times by as much as 70% in our lab tests.
I know there are still many areas that can be improved (photographer ordering interfaces, online statements, die cutting wallets, offering print packages, etc...), but we are documenting your feedback and in effect allowing you to set our development roadmap. If an issue has been mentioned on OSP or the Pictage forums, be assured that we have scrutinized it and are working on a solution.
-------------------------
Ian Siegel
VP Product and Technology
Pictage, Inc.