QUOTE(Lloyd @ May 23 2007, 12:13 PM) [snapback]140380[/snapback]
If you want some well respected lens tests to check it out for yourself, go to:
http://www.pbase.com/lightrules/lenstestsThey're well respected? That's kind of upsetting. Look at their 70-300 vs 70-200 test they put up results that don't compare usefully, show no comparison of chromatic abberation or any actual resolution charts. Then they do a comparison after throwing in a kenko 1.4x tele in there which is going to mess with the optical properties of the lens and completely ruin the results. They do similar things on other test, but the best test they have is the 80 1.8 vs the 125 f2 L. This does a great job of showing how primes are both very good lenses but the colors you get with the L are a bit more realistic.
The only really useful image in the 70-300 vs 70-200 is
this one (bottom images) that shows edge sharpness at the same focal length and same aperture. And that's a great example of what I was talking about. The L lens is far sharper in the edges than the non-L, however you don't need that if you're printing 4x6 or even 8x10 but if you're looking for really A+ results it's all in the details.