Wow this really took off.
QUOTE(Sarah Quiara @ May 4 2007, 08:17 AM) [snapback]129705[/snapback]
It's just a word ... and it's one I'm sure you've said more than a few times. No, I don't teach my kids to say so-called "bad" words, but it says NOTHING about how they're going to grow up or how good of a parent I am if they do say something they shouldn't.
Hey, I'd agree it's just a word, and the child certainly isn't scarred for life for having uttered a "bad word".
But it's not about the word. I even cringed when mom said "you should say, kick it's butt". Huh!?!?!?!? That's better????
Whether you're kicking a butt or an ass is not the issue! Why is a _two year old_ defending her territory by kicking anything???
It's more the mindset of the partent that goes along with it. Parenting doesn't start at age 14 when the child is totally out of control. That parents apparently don't consider where this sort of thing leads. Not the words, but the intentions behind them.
A 2 year old should be learning how to play with other children, how to share, how to be humble and with that goes respect for those in charge over them. And that's the real key - respect. It's not about a word.
A child that young should not be going around with this idea that it's good to puff up your ego and chest and "kick it's ass", "beat up", or "cause the failure of" anything else that comes along that she doesn't agree with. That child should be accepting of and respectful toward pretty well everything she confronts in her little world... she's two!
When something bigger comes along that she doesn't understand she needs to respect it, and if anyone is going to kick anything's butt, it better be mom and dad. At two, that child needs to see and respect things bigger and older than herself, and defer to trusting her parents to deal with said bigger threat. Why is it her responsibility as a 2 year old to defend her terratory against things larger than herself that she doesn't understand?
That child shouldn't have to visualize themselves in a conflict with another person (or monster, or parent, or idea) where one person "kicks ass" and the other "gets their ass kicked". That when something she doesn't understands dares to "come in here" treading on what is apparently her territory, her first instinct isn't to be friendly toward it, or seek to understand it, but to immediately engage in conflict with it - and not because it's a "monster" but because it "came in here".
This kid has somehow picked up the idea that when she's met with something she doesn't understand, she should immediately fight it, and the only way she can be "okay" as a person through the experience is if she wins and it looses.
Hmmm...... it's like I've seen that line of thought elsewhere in the world. When confronted with ideas we don't quite understand we need to first get our feathers ruffled that the idea dared to tread on our territory, the solution is to kill it and gain a sense of pride out of the killing of the idea, person, country, political party, or religious belief of the other guy.
We're teaching our kids that it's good to be the biggest and baddest mo-fo, and that's how you really win in this great life they are embarking on - when everyone else looses. And the quickest way to step over someone else while climbing the hill of life is to put them down and disrespect them. And it would appear kids are doing just that.
QUOTE(ramjpc @ May 4 2007, 09:13 AM) [snapback]129777[/snapback]
There is a family in our neighborhood that has a kid about 6-7 years old. He constantly calls all the kids he doesn't like names and your f-this and f-stupid. He bullies kids around, etc. etc.
Exactly. This poor child has somehow been given the idea that you're only okay when everyone else is so defeated that they'll no longer argue with you. It's not about the bad word, but the fact that he sees the need to throw it at other people. Somehow, somewhere, a parent exposed this child to this line of thinking. If you don't like what the other guy thinks, then "f-them", disrespect them, disregard them, insult them, and go on doing and believing whatever you want in complete disregard to the other guy. Hey, it's all about YOU right?
Then one day this kid gets ahold of a gun and realizes the loud bang, bullets, and blood stains send the "f-them" message a little louder than just swear words. The news media will later go on to blame the laws that allowed this child to have a gun, and nobody will drop their jaw and ask "wow........... how did this child get to age 14, and his only method of conflict resolution was to kill those he disagreed with".
So how do you deal with someone different than you who dares to sit at "your table" in the school lunch room? Yea! You kick the person's ass, of course. Forget asking them their name, having a conversation with them where you may learn something about life you didn't know before, seeing them as another person with feelings also, realizing that you can help make that person happy as easily as making them sad. Nope. Screw all that - it's a pride thing. That other kid is at your table and she doesn't belong there, so you do just what your daddy would do, just what the hero on the shoot-em-up-show did, just what your mom encouraged you to do when you were a baby - and you go kick their ass. She should have known better than to sit at *your* table in the lunchroom. As long as the other person gets thier ass kicked, and you're the one doing the ass kicking, then it's all good.
And if the other guy is too big, you still need to win the ass kicking contest, so the obvious solution is that you need a bigger gun.
Yea, I've seen the continuation of this line of thinking someplace else in the world. Not sure where, but I know I've seen this teaching at work.... somewhere.
Sure, kids are confused. I don't blame the kid. That kid said what she said with attitude and conviction. That's been modeled for her someplace. Maybe her daddy thinks he is too small and weak unless he kicks the asses of the people around him, and he's modeled that for this child, or maybe those TV shows mom and dad watch, when she was just playing on her own with her dolls - maybe she's overheard and picked up what she's seeing - some TV character who is faced with conflict and is glamorized as the "good guy" when he kicks ass. Solve the problem with bullets and dramatic explosions, that always works!
What scares me is that parents say "awww... it's just a word." The question that apparently doesn't smack them in the face is "where did my child pick this up?", and "if the source of this continues to guide my child's conflict resolution skills, what kind of person is she going to turn into?"
Parents don't THINK anymore. The world is all screwed up, and all the screwed up stuff started someplace.
If my kid said that, I wouldn't whip out the camera and encourage it. I would say "remember we watched Monsters, remember the big blue harry one. He was funny wasn't he? What do you think happens when someone gets their 'ass kicked'? They probably get hurt huh? Would it be good to hurt the big cuddly blue monster? I thought he was a good guy? Remember at the start of the move, the kids were scared of him, but once they got to know him, he was actually really funny."
It's almost like, when a child says something like this, she's openeing the door for parents to lovingly guide them. Because what she says here won't define who she is in life, but it will define her next step down the path of life.
Kids don't just wake up one day as out of control teenagers, kids at the corner lot don't put down thier baseballs, pick up thier bats, and start beating the crap out of the kids from the next block over just because they live on the next block over, and people don't just wake up one day in charge of armies and deside the best solution to solve a conflict is to bomb the hell out of the other country because if we insult and demoralize our enemies enough, eventually they'll just give up and become our friends.
It's almost like, you really do get further with honey than with vinigar. That you can learn more from respecting and listening to those around you than by slinging f-bombs and insults at them, and that maybe 99% of the worlds state of being 'all screwed up' would be solved if people would start trying to understand eachother instead of flexing their own pride and know-it-all and endlessly seeking to kick eachother's asses, butts, rear-ends, egos, pride, and will to live.
And there in that moment - a mother who should know better and a confused child willing to follow ANY guidance she's given - that's where "changing the world" starts. Not when she's 18 and voting, but when she's 18 months and listening.
THINK PEOPLE!! THINK!!!